The Institute for Nuclear Theory program, Heavy Flavor and Electromagnetic Probes in Heavy-Ion Collisions (INT 14-3), was held 15 September
to 10 October 2014. In addition to the four organizers: Ramona Vogt (LLNL
and UC Davis), Peter Petreczky (BNL), Anthony Frawley (Florida State),
and Enrico Scomparin (INFN Torino), the program was attended by 34 other
participants spread out over the four week period. Almost all participants
were recognized experts in the field and were invited to take part. Eight of
the participants were postdocs and five were women.
There are two main thrusts to the study of heavy quarks and quarkonia
in heavy-ion physics: "hot matter" (effects specific to the high temperature medium produced in heavy-ion or nucleus-nucleus collisions) and "cold
nuclear matter" (effects that are present already in proton-nucleus collisions
and are a baseline against which hot matter effects must be compared as well
as production of the heavy quarks and quarkonium (bound states of heavy
quark-antiquark pairs) in perturbative QCD.) The program was structured
so that the first two weeks were generally devoted to hot matter, especially
lattice QCD. The second half was devoted to issues related to production and
cold matter effects. An intense 2.5 day workshop, from 29 September to 1
October. Although a theory program, experimentalists attended throughout,
giving talks on recent data and future facilities.
Alexander Rothkopf (Heidelberg University) presented calculations of
quarkonium spectral functions and static quark-antiquark potentials at T >
0, employing a novel Bayesian approach, see e.g. INT-PUB-14-046 and Fig. 1.
Enrico Scomparin (INFN Torino) discussed the ALICE Collaboration results from p+Pb collisions. In particular, he discussed ψ(2S) production
at forward and backward rapidity. At backward rapidity, they find significantly larger suppression than for the more strongly bound J/ψ, see the
left-hand side of Fig. 2. As described by Torsten Dahms (TU Munich), the
CMS Collaboration has also shown results for the ψ(2S), but in Pb+Pb collisions, where, although in a different kinematic region (central rapidity and
transverse momentum larger than 3 GeV/c) they find an enhancement of the
yields compared to J/ψ, shown on the right-hand side of Fig. 2. A consistent
interpretation of these data poses nontrivial problems.
Figure 1: The ϒ spectral function for T = 249 MeV and T = 0 both reconstructed with 12 points in the time direction using the novel Baysian
approach.
Figure 2: (Left) The nuclear modification factor QpPb;mult for the J/ψ and
ψ(2S) states at backward (Pb-going) rapidity, measured by ALICE, as a
function of the centrality of the p+Pb collision (0-20% corresponds to most
central events). (Right) The ratio ψ(2S)/J/ψ for Pb+Pb collisions, normalized to the same quantity in pp, plotted as a function of Npart. The results
are presented for two different pT ranges. The right-most points correspond
to the centrality-integrated sample.